Reasons a Catalytic Converter Can Fail or Work Below Efficiency

The check engine light is your car’s way of warning you about potential problems. One common cause is a faulty or underperforming catalytic converter. This critical component reduces harmful emissions by converting carbon monoxide, hydrocarbons, and nitrogen oxides into less harmful compounds. When it fails or operates below efficiency, your car’s performance, fuel economy, and emissions are affected — and the check engine light often comes on.

What a Catalytic Converter Does

Typical Car Catalytic Converter

The catalytic converter is part of your vehicle’s exhaust system. Its job is to process harmful exhaust gases into safer compounds before they exit the tailpipe. A properly functioning converter helps your car maintain fuel efficiency, run smoothly, and pass smog and emissions tests.

How a Catalytic Converter Triggers the Check Engine Light

Modern cars have oxygen sensors located before and after the catalytic converter. These sensors measure how effectively the converter processes exhaust gases. When the converter is working below efficiency, the sensors detect an imbalance, and the engine control unit (ECU) triggers the check engine light, often storing codes like P0420 or P0430, which indicate “Catalyst System Efficiency Below Threshold.”

Why a Catalytic Converter Can Work Below Efficiency

Several factors can cause a catalytic converter to perform poorly without failing completely:
  • Faulty oxygen sensors: Incorrect air-fuel mixture readings can prevent the converter from processing gases efficiently.
  • Engine misfires: Worn spark plugs, ignition coils, or other issues can send unburned fuel into the exhaust, overheating or contaminating the converter.
  • Clogging or carbon buildup: Over time, carbon deposits reduce airflow through the converter, lowering efficiency.
  • Oil or coolant contamination: Leaks that reach the converter can coat its internal substrate, reducing its ability to convert gases.
  • Age and wear: Like all components, catalytic converters degrade over time, losing some efficiency even if they appear intact.
Even if the converter hasn’t failed completely, these issues can trigger the check engine light and reduce performance.

Signs of a Below-Efficiency Converter

When your catalytic converter isn’t performing properly, you may notice:
  • Reduced acceleration or sluggish engine response
  • Decreased fuel economy
  • Rattling noises from the converter
  • Sulfur or “rotten egg” smell from the exhaust
  • Engine misfires or rough idling

Repair and Replacement Considerations

Catalytic converter replacement is costly — often hundreds to thousands of dollars. Sometimes addressing upstream issues, like oxygen sensors or spark plugs, can restore partial efficiency, but a damaged converter usually requires replacement. Driving with a below-efficiency converter can also harm other components, increasing repair costs over time.